mTLS

Application security is the most important aspect when building for public Internet. You need to encrypt connections with TLS (Transport Layer Security). But what if you want both the client and server to verify each other? That’s where Mutual TLS (mTLS) comes in.

mTLS adds an extra layer of security by requiring both parties to present valid certificates during the TLS handshake. This ensures only trusted clients and servers can communicate.

What is TLS?

TLS is a protocol that encrypts data in transit. It ensures confidentiality, integrity, and authenticity.

• Confidentiality: Data is encrypted so attackers can't read it.
• Integrity: Data can’t be tampered with during transfer.
• Authentication: Servers prove their identity with certificates.

Why Use Mutual Authentication?

Standard TLS authenticates only the server. mTLS verifies both sides, preventing:

• Spoofing: Fake clients pretending to be real users.
• Man-in-the-Middle Attacks: Intercepted and modified requests.

mTLS is especially useful for API security, microservices, and zero-trust networks.

How Mutual TLS Works

Here is how this happens in a sequence diagram showing the flow of events.

1. Client Hello: The client initiates the TLS handshake.
2. Server Certificate: The server sends its certificate.
3. Client Certificate Request: The server asks for a client certificate.
4. Client Certificate: The client sends its certificate.
5. Handshake Completion: If both certificates are valid, the encrypted session starts.

With Beeceptor you can get a Mutual TLS server up and running in a few seconds. You can use it to setup Rest/SOAP APIs and download certificate files for authentication.

Verifying Certificates

Certificates use public-key cryptography. Each party checks the other’s certificate against a Certificate Authority (CA) to confirm it’s trusted.

Example: If you visit example.com, your browser checks the server’s certificate against a known CA (like Let’s Encrypt). mTLS adds the same step for the client.

Key Components of mTLS

Let’s break it down into core components of mTLS

• X.509 Certificates: These are digital documents that act like 'identity cards' for servers and clients. They holds information like the entity’s public key, the CA that issued the certificate, expiration dates, and more to identify the entity. The certificates prove the identity of the communicating parties.

• Certificate Authority (CA): This is a trusted third-party organization that issues and signs certificates. By signing a certificate, the CA vouches for the identity of the entity holding the certificate. For example, Let’s Encrypt is a widely used public CA (and free!), but organizations can also run private CAs for internal systems.

• Public and Private Key Pairs: TLS relies on asymmetric encryption. Each party has a public key (shared with others) and a private key (kept secret). The public key encrypts data, and the corresponding private key decrypts it. The private keys never transmit over the network. This mechanism secures data exchange and proves ownership of a certificate.

• TLS Handshake: This is the initial process where both parties exchange certificates, verify each other's identities, and negotiate encryption parameters before starting secure communication.

Example Certificate (PEM Format):

-----BEGIN CERTIFICATE-----
MIIDXTCCAkWgAwIBAgIJALfXy/...
-----END CERTIFICATE-----

Setting Up Mutual TLS

Let’s walk through setting up mTLS step by step.

Generating Certificates with OpenSSL

Generate a server certificate:

openssl req -x509 -newkey rsa:4096 -keyout server.key -out server.crt -days 365

Generate a client certificate:

openssl req -newkey rsa:4096 -keyout client.key -out client.csr
openssl x509 -req -in client.csr -CA server.crt -CAkey server.key -CAcreateserial -out client.crt -days 365

Configuring Servers

Nginx Example

server {
    listen 443 ssl;
    ssl_certificate /etc/nginx/server.crt;
    ssl_certificate_key /etc/nginx/server.key;
    ssl_client_certificate /etc/nginx/ca.crt;
    ssl_verify_client on;
}

Caddy Example

https://your-secure-api.com {
    tls {
        client_auth { 
            mode require
            trusted_ca_cert_file /etc/caddy/ca.crt
        }
    }
    reverse_proxy localhost:8080
}

Testing with cURL

Test your setup with cURL:

curl --cert client.crt --key client.key https://your-secure-api.com

If the handshake succeeds, you’ll get a response!

Use Cases and Benefits

mTLS is valuable for a variety of scenarios across different domains:

• API Security: Only trusted clients access your API. Example: A banking API uses mTLS to ensure only approved apps can access account data.
• Microservices Communication: Services within a cluster securely communicate without exposing internal traffic. Example: In a Kubernetes environment, mTLS ensures microservices interact securely, preventing lateral movement by attackers.
• Zero Trust Networks: Every connection is verified, even inside a protected network. Example: A healthcare organization uses mTLS to verify devices accessing patient records, even within their internal network.
• IoT Device Security: Authenticate devices in the field, preventing rogue devices from connecting. Example: A smart home system uses mTLS to ensure only certified devices can connect to the home hub.
• B2B Integrations: Secure connections between business partners. Example: A logistics company integrates with suppliers via mTLS-protected APIs, ensuring only authorized suppliers can access shipment data.

mTLS reduces attack surfaces across these scenarios by requiring mutual verification at every connection point.

Real-World Examples

• API Security: A health-tech platform could use mTLS to ensure only authorized apps access sensitive patient data. The client (app) presents its certificate, and the server verifies it before serving the request.
• IoT Device Communication: In a smart home system, devices (like security cameras and door sensors) can use mTLS to securely talk to the control hub, preventing rogue devices from infiltrating the network.
• Internal Microservices: A financial services platform with dozens of microservices can use mTLS to protect service-to-service communication. Even if an attacker breaches the network, they can't interact with services without a valid certificate.

Performance Considerations

mTLS comes with performance trade-offs that you should carefully manage, especially in large-scale deployments. Let’s break down the impact and how you can mitigate potential bottlenecks.

Potential Performance Impacts

• Handshake Overhead: The TLS handshake process becomes more complex with mutual authentication. Each new connection requires verifying both server and client certificates, which adds latency. For high-throughput applications, this delay can accumulate and cause noticeable slowdowns.
• Resource Usage: Cryptographic operations for certificate verification, encryption, and decryption consume CPU and memory resources. In resource-constrained environments like IoT devices or edge computing, this can reduce overall system efficiency.
• Scalability Challenges: Managing and rotating thousands (or millions) of certificates can introduce bottlenecks. For example, if your server needs to validate certificates against an external Certificate Authority (CA), network latency or CA availability issues might affect response times.

Optimizing Performance

Despite the overhead, you can design your system to balance security and speed. Here’s how:

• Session Resumption: Use TLS session resumption (via session tickets or session IDs) to avoid performing a full handshake on every new connection. This is especially useful for APIs with frequent, short-lived requests.
• Load Balancing & TLS Termination: Offload TLS termination to a dedicated reverse proxy (like Envoy, HAProxy, or Nginx). These proxies can handle certificate verification and distribute traffic to backend services, reducing the burden on your main application servers.
• Certificate Caching: Cache validated certificates for a configurable duration. This way, subsequent requests from the same client don’t trigger repetitive validations, cutting down on cryptographic overhead.
• Connection Pooling: Reuse secure connections for multiple requests instead of establishing new TLS sessions for every API call. For instance, a microservices-based system can maintain long-lived connections between services to reduce handshake frequency.
• Optimized Cipher Suites: Choose modern, efficient cipher suites (like TLS_AES_128_GCM_SHA256) that balance security and computational cost.

Example: Scaling mTLS in a FinTech API

Imagine a fintech company exposing an API for mobile banking. Every app instance uses mTLS to access the API. Without optimizations, thousands of simultaneous connections could overwhelm the servers. By using session resumption and terminating TLS at an Envoy proxy, they reduce handshake overhead while maintaining client verification.

Scalability and Automation

Managing certificates at scale can be a headache. Here’s how you can simplify it:

• Automated Cert Management: Use tools like Certbot, CFSSL, or HashiCorp Vault.
• Service Mesh Integration: Platforms like Istio and Linkerd handle mTLS transparently.
• Dynamic Certificate Rotation: Automate certificate renewal and distribution to avoid downtime.

Example: In a Kubernetes cluster, Istio automatically provisions and rotates mTLS certificates for your services.

Best Practices for Implementing mTLS

• Certificate Rotation: Use short-lived certificates (e.g., 90 days) to minimize risk.
• Logging & Monitoring: Log TLS handshake failures and monitor for anomalies.
• Least Privilege Access: Issue certificates with the minimum required permissions.
• Granular Policies: Use metadata (like SANs) to enforce fine-grained access control.
• Revocation Mechanisms: Regularly check for revoked certificates using CRL or OCSP.
• Backup CAs: Maintain backup Certificate Authorities in case of failure.

---

That’s a wrap! Mutual TLS is a powerful way to lock down client-server communication, verifying both sides of a connection to block unauthorized access. Sure, it takes some setup, but the security payoff is huge.

Want to try it out? Beeceptor supports mTLS for testing and development — It is perfect for experimenting and simulating API behaviors. Give it a spin! 🚀